Tonight my son came home to tell me that you gave him advice for me—advice on how *I* can help Duke do a better
job with his homework. As Duke began to tell me, “Mr. Smartypants said what you should do is distract Zilla and Princessa and make a quiet place for me so I can get my work done. Say.. from 3:30 to 5 or something.” I felt very much like Ursula the octopus from the little mermaid. Growing ever larger and taller until I could begin to swing and take my wrath out on the school below me. I think my voice, now growl, even began to sound like hers.
Before I call you and yell, “Who the hell do you think you are?” Let me give you a little background. For the last seven years I have been doing homework, each night, with a son who did not want to do his homework. A son so delicate that the least little thing would drive him to tears and prolong the pain for both of us. Even though I have two other, younger children, I managed to make time for him. Sure, there were times I was nursing a baby while building a Lego tower with the other and also going over math facts with Duke after I had just singlehandedly made dinner for the lot (actually, 2 dinners since there is one picky eater in my house who always gets an alternate meal) after a full day of care giving, building websites, and that pesky masters degree that I was doing, on the side, too. Now each evening I have two children to help with homework. Neither of them want to do it. Both of them want dear ole’ mom to help (and their father works, so it’s just me here) Is there a quiet private area for Duke to do his homework? We have a one story 1400 square foot house with a family of five. I defy you to find that quiet/private spot. Of course, had you investigated, you would have known that Duke is home a full 90 minutes before that annoying brother you want me to distract and could easily find some quiet time in his own room, on the desk his father built for him.
Last year I watched my son begin to crumble in school. He was doing terribly and his spirit was being crushed. Even though I still work from home and have 2 younger children, I decided I had to rescue my son and pulled him out to home school him. Was it a lot of work and a decision I made with great trepidation? You bet your ass it was. Do I regret it? I think his current 92 overall average is a testament to what I did with this boy. When I pulled him out he was failing nearly EVERY subject. Today? He will likely be on the high honor roll list, maybe even the principals list for the first marking period.
And finally, I just want to point out that I initially sent my son to school already reading, already above grade level in every subject. And how was he returned to me? Sad and feeling as if he wasn’t smart. After teaching him for 6 months I have sent him, again, a boy with renewed confidence, diligently working every night on his homework, doing amazing on tests, and having an overall A average. Before you send this boy home with an armful of contrived advice for ME, I think it is YOU that needs to make sure that you’re doing everything YOU can to ensure Duke’s success. Either that, or I’ll take him back and do it myself.

Subscribe to this RSS feed
15 comments:
I'm willing to bet money this guidance counselor has no children. Funny how the child-free always have such great ideas for improved parenting.
oH, you poor thing. Sounds like this guidance counselor has a one-track mind and no idea of what your life is about. Sleep on it tonight - and I'm sure you'll be calmer and know how to better proceed in the morning. From what you write you are doing an amazing job juggling everything/everyone in your life! I could never do it, that's for sure.
More than presumptuous. Especially if there is a 90 minute gap before the younger one gets home.
You did well. Time for a chocolate!
Oh! You go girl! I hope you deliver this to him... in person with large boots on. GRRRRR!
Sounds like the guidance counselor didn't even read the file to realize you just homeschooled - obviously you know how to help your kid get homework done. What an amazing job you've been doing!
Thanks for all your positive back-patting comments. It's so appreciated!!
I think it is incredible that this person did not pick up the phone and speak to you, rather than have your son deliver the message. I would have gone crazy, too!
I agree with Alexandra. It sounds like this teacher was just passing judgment without knowing a thing!! Oh god help me when baby girl's teachers do this bulldoggy stuff.
Amen sister. Well put. There's another FUNDAMENTAL question here -- why are we giving such little kids SO MUCH homework in the first place? Maybe the real problem lies there. There was a very interesting article in Mothering Magazine about this. The conclusion: there is absolutely NO correlation between homework in grade school and junior high and college success. Some studies suggest the opposite. Why can't our school system do their job, stop meddling, and let kids be kids?
The things kids are told in school never cease to amaze me. I'm sure many can relate to this post!
Totally with you. And why is it always about the mother? I wanted to know that, too. Why didn't the counselor suggest that one of his parents do this? Why did he assume that it was mom's job? I'm guessing this guy does not have children or does not do much to raise his own, otherwise he would know what asinine advice he was offering in the first place.
So how about some advice for the teacher. Set aside some time after your day of classes and mandated school committee meetings and read the files of your students so you really know them. Ask questions before you shell out advice. And finally, don't criticize somebody who can hurl a bloggers pixels at you.
VERA!! I'm dying from laughter!! When I rewrite my letter, I'm SOOOOO including your enlightened helpful tips.. hehehehhee.. (evil laugh)
You sound like a fabulous mom. Yay, you. I would support you in strongly considering "taking him home and doing it yourself". I unschool my two and am constantly amazed at what curious, happy kids they are. Big, BIG emphasis on the happy part. If you ever decide to bring them all home again, do this: take a photo of them now, close-up portraits, and a photo of them in six months. You will be knocked out at the changes.
Yay, you.
Hi,
I just gave you an award: http://sunnespot.blogspot.com/2009/10/kreativ-blogger-award.html
Post a Comment